Resource
4 min read · Jul 19, 2026
Contents
Ask two different people what a saddle's "size" means and you can get two different, equally correct, answers. A rider who says "I ride a 17 inch saddle" is talking about seat size — a measurement of the saddle built to fit the rider. A fitter who says a horse "measures a 5" is talking about gullet width — a completely different measurement, on a completely different scale, taken from the horse's back. Same word, two unrelated numbers, describing two different things entirely.
This isn't a sign you're missing something obvious — the confusion is baked into the terminology itself. The word "size" gets used loosely for both across tack shops, classified ads and casual conversation, with nothing in the word to tell you which one is meant. The only way through it is knowing both numbers exist, what each one actually measures, and which one you're being asked for in a given conversation.
English seat size is measured from the pommel nail — a small stud on the near side of the pommel, the raised front of the seat — back to the center of the cantle, the raised back edge of the seat, in inches. Adult seat sizes typically fall somewhere around 15 to 18 inches, with junior and pony saddles running smaller, though that range is a general guide rather than a hard boundary. Seat size depends on a rider's actual leg length, hip width and build, not just height, so two riders of similar height can genuinely need different seat sizes.
Western seat size is measured differently: typically from the base of the horn, or the swell just behind it, back to the center of the cantle — different reference points, on a saddle with a different overall shape. That difference in measuring convention is part of why the same rider is commonly said to need a Western seat about an inch smaller than their English seat, though treat that as a rough starting guess rather than a reliable conversion — it varies enough by maker and saddle style that it isn't a fixed rule.
A seat-size number on a spec sheet is a starting point, not a guarantee. The classic rule of thumb is to sit in the saddle, settle into a normal, balanced position, and check for roughly a hand's width of space between your seat and the cantle behind you — not crammed against it, not swimming in extra room either. How much room actually feels right varies by discipline, though: close-contact seats built for jumping fit snugger by design, while a roomier Western pleasure or trail seat leaves more space on purpose. A number tells you where to start looking. Sitting in the saddle is what actually tells you whether it fits.
Gullet width and wither profile describe the horse's back. Seat size describes the rider's own leg, hip and build. Neither number predicts the other, because they're not measuring the same thing, or even the same subject. A tall rider and a small rider can both ride the same horse comfortably in saddles that share the exact same gullet width — sized correctly for that one horse — while needing completely different seat sizes from each other. The reverse is just as true: two horses with very different back shapes can both suit saddles built around the same rider's seat size, as long as each saddle's tree is separately correct for its own horse.
That's really the whole point worth taking from this: shopping for a saddle means solving two separate fitting problems at the same time, not one. Getting the horse-side number right doesn't tell you anything about whether the seat will fit you, and getting a seat size that's comfortable for you doesn't tell you anything about whether that saddle's tree suits your horse.
Want to measure instead of guess? See why we recommend a SaddleGauge.
Go into a saddle search expecting to need both numbers, not one. The horse-side half of the equation — gullet width, wither profile — is covered in depth elsewhere on this site, and it's worth having a real measurement rather than a guess before you start looking seriously. The rider-side half is simply about you, and there's no substitute for actually sitting in a saddle, or having an experienced fitter or tack shop measure you, especially before you've sat in more than one or two saddles and gotten a feel for what "right" feels like. Neither number matters more than the other — a saddle that's wrong for either the horse or the rider is a saddle that doesn't fit, full stop.
Related reading
A free, maintained directory of saddle makers, tree makers and fitters — run by the makers of SaddleGauge, and built to genuinely help riders find saddle fit.
Browse
Get in touch
Spot something wrong? Email us to correct or remove a listing.
© 2026 SaddleHelp. Listings are free — this directory is run for goodwill, not profit.